When Worlds Collide

"There are now plans to reflect adverts off the moon", said Professor Justin Lewis, as he argued that all television is ultimately driven by a hidden consumerism.  That was just one of the many insights gained as the Wales Centre paired academics with television professionals for one-to-one dialogue and debate at Cardiff University’s School of Journalism, Media and Cultural Studies on the 24th October.

Karin Wahl-Jorgensen reported that the BBC is still trapped in a two major-party world when it comes to political reporting, while Jenny Kitzinger told us that the portrayal of people in a coma in hospital drama is not only wrong but actually misleads the public.  Other subjects discussed included news provision for the younger teen audience, and an attempt to define what the ‘mainstream’ means within commercial British television.

Mike Talbot from ITV Wales said that cage fighting and cuts to council services were both current and mainstream, but that only one was really popular with audiences.  So which programme offered true public service broadcasting?  As the academics would say – discuss!

 

Update:  Angela Graham, one of the organisers, wrote a short blog reflecting on the event, including:-

"Pleasingly, Expertise Exchange produced three ongoing projects: Prof Jenny Kitzinger and Erika Hossington on a potential storyline for ‘Casualty’ about people in vegetative states; Dr Ross Garner and Mike Talbot on producing TV for the ‘mainstream’ in Wales and Dr Cindy Carter and BBC Broadcast journalist, Huw Foulkes on news production for young teenagers."